Greetings North Dakota ASPIRE!
The following is a copy of the State Initiative report that I gave at the ND ASPIRE State Meeting in Cheyenne on October 10th, 2010. It contains information on the Interim Education, Higher Education, and Workforce committees, as well as links to the National Governors’ Association Core State Standards website, legislative recommendations from the ND Youth Council, legislative recommendations from the ND Commission on Education Improvement, and revised 1st year college placement policies adopted by the North Dakota State Board of Education on June 17th, 2010. Please let me know if you have any names for our ND TRIO Alumni and Friends E-Mail List so that we can increase the number of advocates who receive our ND Legislative Updates and Action Alerts. You may also invite people to submit their contact information via the CONTACT tab on the ND ASPIRE homepage at www.ndaspire.org. Once I receive their contact information, I will send them a Welcome message and a brief explanation. Mary
******************************************************************
During the 2009-2010 Legislative Interim the State Initiative has been monitoring the work of the Interim Education, Higher Education and Workforce committees because of its relevance to North Dakota ASPIRE. The 2009 Legislature asked these committees to study particular issues, and draft bills pertinent to them for the 2011 Session. These committees will be wrapping up there work by the end of October.
The 2011 Organizational Session will be held Dec. 6th-8th, 2010 and the Session itself will begin on Jan. 4th and run until April 27th. During the organizational session legislators will be assigned to the standing committees in their respective houses, and bills coming from interim committees, the executive (including the North Dakota State University System), will also be filed. Once the Session begins, legislators will be allowed to introduce new bills until Jan. 17th in the House, and Jan. 24th in the Senate. February 25this “Crossover Day” the day when all bills originating in the Senate must be sent to the House, and vice versa. The North Dakota Legislative Action Blog will begin publishing information on draft bills as early as late November and continue this effort throughout the 2011 Session. Please watch for our e-mail alerts!
Interim Committee Highlights
The Interim Education Committee spent the majority of its time studying school approval and accreditation criteria and the consequences to schools and school districts that fail to meet these criteria. They also heard from American Indian school administrators and community leaders regarding governance and finance issues faced by schools in their communities. To date I am unsure what the Committee’s recommendations on these issues might be, since it has not yet completed its bill drafts for the 2011 Session.
The Committee also received a report from the North Dakota Commission on Education Improvement on that group’s examination of graduation requirements, curricular standards, assessments, and recommendations for improving student performance and instructional quality, including a report on the ND Academic Merit and Career and Technical Scholarship programs.
The Interim Higher Education Committee spent a lot of time studying different higher education finance models, including performance funding based on institutional productivity in the areas of research, student access, success, and workforce training. They brought in several consultants to talk about higher education finance, andto talk about other states’ experience with performance-based funding. Interim Higher Education also reconvened the Higher Education Roundtable made up of 42 representatives, from business, industry, the State Board, public and private higher education institutions, and the executive branch. The Roundtable is to make recommendations on how the state’s higher education system can be responsive to the state’s future needs. As you may recall this was also the intent of the first Higher Education Roundtablewhich met from 1999 through the early 2000’s. To find out whether there are members of your community on the Roundtable, a list of Roundtablemembers can be found in the 9/13/10 minutes of the Higher Education at : http://www.legis.nd.gov/assembly/61-2009/interim-info/minutes/he091310minutes.pdf At its next meeting in October, Interim Higher Education will receive a report from the North Dakota State University System on the number of Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarships awarded in 2010, along with demographic information about the recipients. They will also complete their bill drafts at that time.
The Legislature created the Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarship programs in 2009. During the Interim, the Workforce Committee has been looking at ways to provide a permanent funding source for the scholarships to avoid having to pass an appropriation for them every two years.
As part of its deliberations, Interim Workforce interviewed an administrator from the Wyoming Department of Education on that state’s Hathaway Scholarship Program, funded by Wyoming’s Permanent Mineral Trust Fund. In 2005 the Wyoming Legislature created a $400 Million permanent endowment to provide scholarships to Wyoming high school graduates who attend college in the state. Although the Hathaway Program is a merit-based program based on GPA, and ACT requirements, it does provide support at three different achievement levels, unlike the North Dakota program which awards only the top students. In your handout you will find a comparison of the Wyoming and North Dakota Programs. Another positive aspect of the Wyoming program is that GED students and part-time students can also receive awards. (Students with 2.5 GPA’s and composite ACT scores of 19 receive $800/semester for 8 full-time semesters as long as they maintain a cumulative college GPA of 2.25; students with high school GPA’s of 3.0 and an ACT of 21 receive $1200/semester for 8 full-time semesters as long as they maintain 2.5 cumulative college GPA, and students with a 3.5 high school GPA and a 25 ACT score receive $1600/semester for 8 full-time semesters as long as they maintain cumulative college GPA of 2.5. Scholarships are also available to GED students with (scores 500 or above who have received an ACT of 19 or above), part-time students, and students who have been home-schooled.)
Unfortunately no changes were made to the ACT or GPA requirements for the ND Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarships during the Legislative Interim so that more students could receive support. This program is primarily a workforce tool to encourage high achieving students to attend college in North Dakota in hopes that they join the state’s workforce after completing post-secondary education. (The minimum requirements that a student must meet in order to qualify include a 24 ACT, a 3.0 high school GPA for the academic scholarship, and a minimum score of five on three of the WorkKeys tests and a 3.0 high school GPA, and a college GPA of 2.75. GED students and part-time students are not eligible. Students who do qualify are awarded $750/semester for 8 full-time semesters in which they maintain the 2.75 cumulative colleges GPA.)
Proponents of the North Dakota Academic Merit and Career and Technical Scholarship programs estimate that they will cost $10 Million and $16 Million respectively in 2011-2012, and 2012-2013. At their meeting on Sept. 27th, Interim Workforce discussed a bill draft which would allow earnings from the foundation aid stabilization fund to pay for the scholarships for the next two academic years. Proponents of this plan argue that the fund has rarely been used for its intended purpose, (to help schools deal with large drops in enrollment) therefore, it is justifiable to use the earnings to support the new scholarships. To supplement the revenue from this source, the $7 Million has been included in the upcoming budget for the North Dakota State University System. Interim Workforce also discussed a draft resolution to amend the state constitution during the 2011 Session so that the earnings from the foundation aid stabilization fund will automatically go to the Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarship program without the need for an appropriation. If passed, the constitutional amendment will be put to the voters in 2012.
To give you some idea of how many students may benefit from the Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarships for the 2011-2012 academic years, here are some statistics. This information is also in your handout. As you may recall, all NorthDakota juniors were tested via the ACT or WorkKeys test in April 2010, to determine eligibility for the scholarship programs. Approximately 7400 juniors were tested, with 7018 of those taking the ACT, and 375 students taking WorkKeys. Twenty-five percent (1743 ) of those taking the ACT achieved an ACT score of 24 or higher. Fifty-two students, or 14% of those who took the WorkKeys test qualified for the scholarship. So out of nearly 7400 students tested, roughly 24% (1795) achieved a qualifying score.
Interim Workforce also heard a report from the North Dakota Youth Council a 16 member advisory group consisting of youth ages 17-24 which was created by the 2009 Legislature. The Lt. Governor and four legislators also serve on the Council. Group members were appointed by the Governor in September 2009 and since that time the Governor’s Senior Education Policy Advisor, Kayla Effertz, has been overseeing its work. The Youth Council, also known as Youth Forward was asked to develop recommendations on how to meet the challenges faced by North Dakota youth in education, employment, healthcare, and recreation. The Youth Council’s recommendations were well received by Interim Workforce who heard their final report on Sept. 27th. It is highly likely that bills to implement Youth Council recommendations will be sponsored by Workforce. In your handout you will find a list of Youth Council recommendations for education. Note the similarity to TRIO best practices. The recommendations are as follows:
- Establish a “Virtual High School for Scholars” in order to increase the number of dual-credit and AP course offerings
- Implement student-to-student peer education programs on campuses and in high schools to increase retention rates
- Grant credit to student mentors involved in these programs
- Require a first-year experience course for college freshmen that includes a peer mentoring component and approval of a plan of study by an academic advisor
- Provide a sustainable funding source for the Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarship programs
- Embed financial literacy into the elementary, secondary, and post-secondary curriculum.
For more information on the Youth Council Report and its members, a link to the Youth Forward website can be found at http://ndyouthforward.wordpress.com/youth-council/
Since recommendations from the North Dakota Commission on Education Improvementare having a significant impact on NorthDakota’s education landscape, I wanted to share with you a summary of recommendations made by the Commission at the joint meeting of Interim Higher Education and the Higher Education Roundtable on Sept. 13th. These are in your handout, as well. (1.) The Commission is recommending that North Dakota continue to work with other states to implement common core standards and assessments for K-12 education in the areas of language arts, mathematics, physical science and social studies. As you may know, this was an effort spearheaded by the National Governor’s Association. North Dakota was one of 48 states and two territories who participated in the development of the standards on a voluntary basis. The final version of the standards was released in June, 2010. For more information on the standards here is a link to the Common Core Standards website: http://www.corestandards.org/.
(2.) For the upcoming biennium, the ND Commission on Education Improvement is recommending that the Legislature fund two pilot projects to improve language arts alignment between high schools and institutions of higher education. (3.)In addition the Commission has recommended that the Legislature also provide funding to expand the ND Center for Distance Education, including an expansion of online AP and dual credit offering, and (4.) and appropriations for tuition subsidies to ND high school students enrolling in online classes, (5.) a recommendation that a permanent funding source be established for the ND Academic Merit and Career and Technical scholarships, and finally (6.) that the NDUS adopt and continuously monitor certain uniform standards for placement in 1st year college courses, including an 18 ACT for placement in English 110 at 2 and 4 year colleges, a 21 ACT for placement in Math 103 at 2 year colleges, and a 22 at four-year colleges, and a suggested 21 ACT at both 2 and 4 year institutions for placement in introductory Social Science courses, and a suggested 24 ACT at both 2 and 4 year colleges for placement in introductory Physical Science courses. Actually, the State Board of Higher Education did adopt these uniform placement standards at its June 17th meeting. According to the minutes for the June 17th minutes of the State Board of Higher Education, and scheduled to go into effect in fall 2012. Students aged 25 and older are exempt from these recommendations. See pages 4-5 of the June 17th , 2010 minutes of the State Board of Higher Education for a complete description of the new policies on admissions and developmental courses contained in sections 402.1.1,402.1.2, 402.2, and 403.9 of the North Dakota State Board of Higher Education Policy Manual. http://www.ndus.edu/uploads/document-library/2376/6-17-10-SBHE-WEB-MINUTES.PDF
We can expect that many Commission for Education Improvement recommendations will be included in bills introduced during the 2011 Session.